Guide

Rewarding profit: A loyalty buyer’s guide for growing brands

Launch smarter. Scale with confidence.

This guide is for marketers who are looking for a partner to launch a simple, scalable program. If you already have a program in place and want to drive more engagement, revenue, and emotional loyalty, check out the Loyalty program optimization guide for practical tips on personalization, onboarding, and measuring success​. Looking for a deeper dive? Explore the Buyer’s guide to enterprise loyalty management.

Why loyalty, why now?

Discount-heavy promotions can hurt profits over time. Many brands offer the same discounts to everyone, without asking customers to qualify. This one-size-fits-all approach conditions consumers to wait for deals instead of buying at full price. It also makes it hard for brands to protect long-term revenue and can eventually force you to raise prices across the board to make up for lost margin.

For example, a 5 % discount means you need at least 20 % more sales just to keep a 30 % gross margin. That’s not easy to maintain.

A smarter approach is to use a loyalty program built on the right strategy. It rewards the right behavior, protects your margins, and helps you grow profit over time.

Three areas to think about when evaluating your loyalty needs

As you start shaping your loyalty approach, it helps to think in three broad categories. These give you a simple framework to assess your needs:

  1. Strategy
    What’s the goal of your program? Who are your customers, and what motivates them? How does loyalty fit into your overall brand experience?
  2. Technology
    What tools or platform capabilities do you need to deliver your strategy? Do you require real-time personalization, mobile capabilities, or easy integrations?
  3. Support and services
    What internal or external resources will you need? Can a partner help with execution, creative, campaign setup, and troubleshooting?

Top tip: Starting with technology is tempting, but the most successful loyalty programs start with strategy. When brands lead with tech, they often end up overpaying for features they don’t use or missing the ones they truly need. Beginning with a clear strategy helps you choose a platform that supports your goals today and scales with you tomorrow. Some full-service partners like Marigold include all three areas as part of their loyalty offering: strategy, technology, and support.

What are you trying to solve for?

Before exploring customer retention features, identify the outcomes that matter most to your business, customers, and brand.

What matters for your business?

  • Should loyalty go beyond customer retention?
  • How do you measure and manage customer lifetime value?
  • Do you only rely on discounts to stimulate sales?

What matters to your customers?

  • What level of personalization do you need to deliver?
  • What are your customers’ most significant pain points?
  • How can you sustainably deliver value and be differentiated?

What matters for your brand?

  • How critical is an emotional connection with the brand?
  • How does your brand’s authenticity drive the business?
  • Can customers trust you to deliver on brand promises?
"Growing brands need marketer-friendly technology to support their objectives on day one. Success requires a strong alignment with strategy and the ability to seamlessly scale with the natural growth of your program."
— Roger Williams, Head of Loyalty Center of Excellence, Marigold

Choose the right type of partner

There are many types of loyalty providers, and each offers different strengths depending on where you are in your loyalty journey.

  • Strategy consultants help design a loyalty approach, select platforms, and align internal stakeholders. They typically don’t handle execution.
  • Technology vendors provide platforms but often lack flexibility, requiring you to fit your program to their tech and manage execution separately.
  • Specialist service providers can support specific loyalty needs, such as data analytics or campaign creative, but require coordination across vendors.
  • Full-service partners combine all three: strategy, technology, and services, streamlining delivery, support, and accountability.

Top tip: For growing brands, a full-service model often makes the most sense. When you’re moving fast or wearing multiple hats, working with a single partner who can support your strategy, program launch, operations, and program growth helps remove friction and accelerate results. Marigold’s offering spans all four areas listed above, so you can launch with confidence and scale at your own pace. Whether you’re just getting started or building out a more advanced program, our solutions adapt to your evolving needs.

What makes a good loyalty partner?

A strong loyalty partnership helps you deliver results across three core areas: strategy, technology, and support.

Strategy: What is your game plan?

As a football coach creates a game plan to prepare his team, your loyalty program needs a strategy. The right partner will help you define a loyalty strategy that fits your business goals, customer needs, and brand values. That includes helping you choose the proper structure, rewards model, and messaging approach without overwhelming your team.

Marigold Loyalty offers brands strategic services, supported by loyalty experts who specialize in QSR, retail, and more. Pre-built templates, non-discount-focused plays, and best-practice campaign designs are included to help marketers get started with confidence.

"We are seeing the early stages of a fundamental shift in how brands deliver loyalty. There will be more demand for a traditional rewards approach that drives incrementality. We need to realign rewards with the brand's core product offerings versus only redeeming for discount coupons."
— Roger Williams, Head of Loyalty Center of Excellence, Marigold

Technology: Launch fast and scale with ease.

You want technology that supports your needs today and gives you room to grow. Look for platforms that offer flexible features, real-time personalization, and integration capabilities without a long lead time or heavy IT lift.

Marigold Loyalty offers technology options for brands of all sizes and maturity levels, from Loyalty Essentials, our module for growing brands, to our full, enterprise-scale Loyalty platform. Brands can launch a fully provisioned program in as little as 30 days.* Benefit from loyalty templates and configurable tools built with the knowledge and experience of our loyalty experts. Launch confidently, knowing that your program is built on the same platform that powers some of the world’s most complex, high-scale loyalty programs.

Acronym definitions: SOW – Statement of work; SSD – Solutions specification document; BRD – Business requirements document; UAT – User Acceptance Testing; BAU – Business as usual



Support and services: Designed for real-world teams.

Look for a partner that won’t leave you hanging after launch. Training materials, accessible documentation, and a responsive services team can make all the difference when you’re moving quickly or when short on internal resources.

Marigold Loyalty includes step-by-step user guides and built-in support options to help your team stay confident and self-sufficient after setup.

16 questions to ask before you buy

Before you commit to a loyalty solution, make sure your potential partner can support your needs today and grow with you tomorrow. Here are 16 questions to ask any vendor during the evaluation process:

Program design and launch

  1. How quickly can we launch a fully functional loyalty program?
  2. Do you offer onboarding support or strategic services to help design our program?
  3. Are pre-built templates or campaign frameworks available to help us get started confidently?
  4. Can we start simple and add features or complexity later?

Functionality and flexibility

  1. What types of loyalty structures do you support, e.g., points, tiers, referrals, non-discount rewards?
  2. Can we personalize offers and segment customers using customer data like preferences and behaviors?
  3. How flexible is the program configuration? Can we update offers, triggers, or tiers without custom development?
  4. What level of customization is possible? How easy is it to manage without ongoing development support?

Technology fit

  1. How well does the platform integrate with our existing systems (POS, CRM, mobile apps, etc.)?
  2. Will we own our customer data, and how is it stored, accessed, and protected?
  3. Does your platform support real-time actions, mobile engagement, or cross-channel execution?

Support and growth

  1. What kind of post-launch support is included—training, help center access, or ongoing services?
  2. What kind of day-to-day support will our team have access to?
  3. What strategic services do you offer to help optimize the program after launch?
  4. How do you help brands measure success, both in terms of customer engagement and ROI?
  5. How scalable is the platform as our program grows across markets, segments, or use cases?

Final thought: Start simple, stay smart

Complexity doesn’t equal success. You don’t need to build a complicated loyalty program from day one. What matters is starting with clear goals, a thoughtful structure, and a partner who can evolve with you.
Here are three ways to set your program up for success:

  • Pick one priority. Focus on a single business goal—like increasing second purchases, reducing discounting, or gathering better data—and build from there.
  • Keep it simple. Choose a program structure that your customers will understand and engage with, whether that’s points, tiers, referrals, or a mix.
  • Build for flexibility. Select a partner who supports iteration, not lock-in. Your program should grow with your brand, not box you in.

With the right strategy, tools, and support, your brand can build a loyalty program that delivers real impact, now and in the future.

Top tip: Even if your brand is at an earlier stage, you can still get inspiration from enterprise-scale programs. For example, KFC launched a successful loyalty program with Marigold that blends points, personalization, and gamification. One year in, KFC Rewards exceeds 6.4 million members. Read What marketers can learn from the rise of KFC Rewards to find out how they made it happen.

Ready to take the next step?

If you’re exploring how to turn these ideas into action, we’d love to help. Whether you have questions, want to see what a loyalty program could look like for your brand, or just want to explore what’s possible, our team is here for you.

Get in touch with our loyalty experts

*Thirty days is the timeline to create and configure a customer’s loyalty program within the Marigold platform. This does not include the timeline to integrate, test, and go live.